Second Grave poster
plusSecond level tier imageS&S NightmaresSeason 1

Second Grave

31 min 40 s
2.5k Listeners
2 Comments

Detectives fear the worst after a 9-year-old girl goes missing, and an empty grave is discovered in the nearby woods.

Share With:
2.5k Listeners
2 Comments

Detectives fear the worst after a 9-year-old girl goes missing, and an empty grave is discovered in the nearby woods.

Delving deeper into the bone-chilling true crime narrative of nine-year-old Elizabeth Olsen's brutal murder, this podcast episode carefully dissects the sequence of tragic events that led to her untimely death. It provides a thorough examination of the intensive police investigation that ensued, highlighting the relentless efforts of law enforcement to bring the perpetrator to justice. The episode takes a dramatic turn as it reveals the shocking confession of the teenage assailant, Alyssa Bustamante, whose disturbing actions sent ripples of horror through the community.


Listeners are guided through the meticulous details of the case, from the initial disappearance of young Elizabeth to the grim discovery of her body. The podcast delves into the psychological profile of Bustamante, attempting to shed light on what could drive a teenager to commit such a heinous act. It also explores the complex legal proceedings that followed, including the trial, sentencing, and the broader implications of juvenile justice in such severe cases.


Throughout the episode, the narrative maintains a respectful tone, mindful of the sensitive nature of the crime and its profound impact on the Olsen family, the local community, and the public at large. The podcast aims to offer a comprehensive and sobering look at the crime and its aftermath, inviting listeners to reflect on the tragedy and the broader societal issues it raises.