Three Strikes poster
plusSecond level tier imageS&S NightmaresSeason 1

Three Strikes

30 min 25 s
2.0k Listeners
0 Comments

A shocking news headline sends minor league baseball player Blake Bivens home in a hurry. Something was happening in his hometown in Virginia and he feared the worst. A tragedy struck that affected the whole community and would change his life forever.

Share With:
2.0k Listeners
0 Comments

A shocking news headline sends minor league baseball player Blake Bivens home in a hurry. Something was happening in his hometown in Virginia and he feared the worst. A tragedy struck that affected the whole community and would change his life forever.

In the quiet expanse of rural Virginia, a true crime story emerges, one that grips the heart with its tragic narrative. This is the story of Blake Bivens, a minor league baseball player, whose life was irrevocably altered by a chilling triple homicide. The victims were his beloved family members: his wife, Emily Bivens, their infant son, Colin Bivens, and Emily's mother, Joan Bernard. The episode delves into the horrifying details of the crime, painting a picture of a day that began like any other and ended in unspeakable tragedy.


The perpetrator of this heinous act was none other than Emily's brother, Matthew Bernard, whose actions on that fateful day sparked a frantic manhunt. The investigation into the killings reveals a complex web of family dynamics and possible motives, leaving the community and law enforcement to piece together the reasons behind such a senseless act.


As the manhunt unfolds, the story also focuses on the emotional turmoil faced by Blake Bivens. The narrative explores the depths of his grief as he confronts a reality where his immediate family has been wiped out in an instant. The episode provides a poignant look at Bivens' journey through pain and sorrow, his struggle to find solace, and the resilience of the human spirit in the face of overwhelming loss.


This true crime story not only recounts the grim details of a family tragedy but also offers a meditation on the impact of violent crime on the survivors and their communities. It's a sobering reminder of the fragility of life and the enduring consequences of one individual's actions on the lives of many.